EmergingIssues

Friday, September 30, 2011

Success for All

Hi Jeff, thank you for your comment relative to competition vs. collaboration.  Unfortunately, in today's climate, the schools are expected to do more with less.  It has been a struggle for at least five years, and school districts are constantly being scrutinized on a daily basis.

Unless the "competition" you address is followed through at home, it will not have an impression on the child.  It's a dilemma and challenge to get everyone on board, particularly with the social networking, peer-pressure, not enough support at school, etc.  Only time will tell.  

Thursday, September 29, 2011

Charter Schools vs. Public Schools

As Lisa pointed out, she is not so sure that she would be supportive of a charter school opening near her town.  I tend to agree.  There are many fine public schools that offer exemplary programs for children; moreover, student motivation should be examined to discuss the success or failure of charter schools vs. public schools.  Collaboration not competition is key for implementing and designing an effective program. 

Sunday, September 25, 2011

Charter Schools Spreading to the Suburbs

“More than half of Americans live in suburbs, and about 1 in 5 of the 4,951 existing charter schools were located there in 2010, federal statistics show. Advocates say many proposed suburban charters have struggled because of a double standard that suggests charters are fine for poor urban areas, but are not needed in well-off neighborhoods.  (Charter School Battle Shifts to Affluent Suburbs, New York Times 7/16/11). 

 I’m not so sure that I would be supportive of a charter school opening near my town.  I think the schools in my suburban neighborhood and surrounding areas function at high levels.  Why are such institutions opening in areas where school districts are providing for children and families in the communities?  Why need to share public funds for education between public and charter schools – especially in areas where an alternative is not needed?  If there is true advantage in how charter schools function, successes should be shared and exemplars used to replicate.  So what is it that makes some of the successful charter schools so wonderful, and why are we not sharing this knowledge and implementing such strategies in our school districts?  If we are working towards the same goals, why remain so distant and distinct?  Perhaps equity between the public and charter school in terms of flexibility and (de) regulations would yield positive results.  “…is the best answer to create scattered small, privately operated schools and hope that the competition will impel district schools to improve? (Charter Schools Spreading to the Suburbs, New York Times, 7/21/11)  I do not think so.  I think collaboration and working towards the same educational goals for all students would be most beneficial. 

Let the discussion continue

Monique presents an insightful response regarding the activities of Fethullah Gulen.  I agree with Monique 's comments referencing homeland security.  Gulen's website is so convincing that some of the information is alarming, and forces you to take notice.

Thursday, September 15, 2011

For Discussion: (Assignment: Sept 15th - October 4th)

Please read, comment as related to course content and public education in general, citing references where possible.    [Minimum of 3 posts each.  Individual personal reflections due (via email) by October 4th.]

'Charter Schools Tied to Turkey Grow in Texas'.   New York Times. June 6, 2011.

 http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/07/education/07charter.html?_r=2&emc=eta1