EmergingIssues

Monday, November 28, 2011

Response to the - Fact Sheet Prepared by the Staff of the New York State Commission on Property Tax Relief (2008)

This was an interesting read and I agree with some of their points. I am curious to know what members made up this NYS Commission (i.e. were there representation beyond business/policy officials?). I agree that special education is very expensive and NYS has more mandates than many other states (and some NYS regulations are stricter than federal regulations sometimes causing confusion). These mandates need to be carefully reviewed and reduced allowing local districts more flexibility to make decisions that are appropriate for a specific student (i.e., currently it is mandated to provide specific services for students classified with autism even though not all students on this disability continuum require the same level of services). This is the right thing for the student while also freeing the district from unwarranted costs. Many parents and educators genuine concern is that once a district is no longer obligated to provide services will they provide it if justified? There is a reason why CSE/IEP meetings (made up of educators not the superintendent or BOE) make decisions which are supposed to be educational relevant and not dependent on fiscal constraints. Our special education attorney advised staff to make educational sound decisions and never say in a meeting “we don’t offer this here” or “we only give a maximum of ______services”. The reason is we are obligated to provide what is appropriate for that specific student’s needs (be able to justify our decision with data) and never make our decisions based on cost. Keeping that in mind, the administrator for special education has to be mindful of finding innovative and equitable ways to provide services while keeping costs down.
I agree with Lisa of the importance for educators to reflect on one’s practice and continually make refinements if a specific program/strategy is not producing positive results. We do need to be careful though what data we are using to measure the effectiveness of special education. It is important to look at the baseline data for an individual child and utilize benchmarks to measure growth. From my on observations, using data (i.e., formative assessments) to drive instruction is an area needing improvement for both special and general education educators. With the new NYS IEPs, IEP goals need to be more specific and measurable. Special Educators appear to be very good at providing the direct intervention but need training in analyzing data to assess student’s progress and change intervention when warranted.
I agree with Monique’s reference to the importance of RTI if done correctly. RTI’s premise is that all children learn at different rates and will require different approaches. Response to Intervention is a framework that provides early tiered intervention for all students struggling and can have a systemic change in many schools. It puts accountability on all educators (no longer special educators alone) to meet the needs of their neediest students instead of removing them from class for remediation. To be most effective, RTI should not be viewed as another “stand alone mandated program” but treated as a true “professional learning community” requiring collective wisdom and responsibility. RTI is a reform initiative that can help facilitate maintaining diverse learners in the general education classroom and reduce some special education costs in the long-term. How? Even though the purpose of RTI is not to reduce a school’s classification rate, it will have an impact by the very nature of providing ALL services a student needs early prior to significant learning gaps develops. This means less IEP meetings, standardized testing for eligibility, and other administrative costs. I do agree with Jeff that this will not make a significant dent in the special education costs for the following reasons: additional supports/staffing will continue to be needed to assist the general educator (difference is the reallocation but not necessarily a reduction) and districts may initially get less state/federal funding because of the reduced classification rate (due to their current calculations for state aide, only 15% of IDEA monies can be used for early intervening services). I don’t necessarily agree with the Commission’s statement that “Special Education is a key driver in the growth of school expense” and that “Special Education should not be required to meet the milder disabilities”. The tone of this fact statement is somewhat negative and lends one to believe that if only we rid ourselves of special education we would have the funds to educate the rest of our youth.
I am a firm believer of integrating students more into the general education (which can look differently for different students based on their needs, there should not be a “one size fits all” approach) and providing the necessary supports for them to succeed (which will cost money if done correctly). I am also a firm believer that the delivery of services needs to change and require an increase in collaboration in order to meet our diverse learners. However, special education does provide a benefit and there will always be students that require these supports and at times a more specialized/restrictive environment.
The role of a special educator needs to evolve to share their expertise and provide consultation services during these times of transition. I do see in the future of education that there will be a “new way of doing things” that will continue to require the supports from specialists just in a different capacity with a greater focus on accountability. RTI and other initiatives (such as Common Core Standards, 21st Century Skills, etc..) can only improve education for all students to learn. Special Education reform is needed to improve student outcomes not necessarily costs. My concern is that change may come under the disguise to make school improvements but the actual agenda is simply to save costs. For example, moving all students into general education classes without the necessary supports (for the teacher as well as the students) would be a great disservice. We need to keep asking ourselves “what is right for kids?” In some schools, the only way struggling students were able to get services was through special education because the school has no other avenues for getting supports. This is not right and students should not be labeled with a disability because of a lack of general education instruction. However, this is still the reality for many schools especially in NYC. It will be a wonderful new day if general education in every school is improved for all students, general education teachers were committed to provide accommodations for specific students without 504s/IEPs, and true collaboration/ownership existed between general/special education staff to make sure each child under their care learns…
I agree with the Commission’s recommendations to reduce the cost of litigations (#1), secure additional federal funding, increase collaboration to enhance local/regional delivery of services, and to promote “best practices” by relieving the districts of some of the “procedural” mandates.

Special Education Costs

As a special educator and director of special education for several years I can attest to the high financial costs of such programs and servicing students with disabilities in our public schools. I know firsthand that the monies set aside are not equitable for all groups of children both because the needs vary across individual students as well as some parents know how to work the system to get districts to agree to costly settlements. In the past four years as director, I lowered the special education costs significantly by bringing students back into district (long-term savings), permitting out of district students to enroll in our special education programs (tuition paid), and taking a close look at our related service providers (conducting RFPs and developing a collaborative partnership with these agencies). Even with those cuts, the special education budget still made up a large portion of the district budget (largely due to staffing, a few costly settlement agreements, and projected crisis intervention costs covering all students in need) .
I agree with Paul's statement that "the needs of students differ and sometimes a student needs a different approach than others. If we are servicing the students in the same system...we should expect to pay more for some students". Fairness in not treating everyone equal. The key is to be equitable the best you can and make sure you are providing students with a free & appropriate public education! We need to examine the issue of educating students with disabilities with a historical perspective. Parents fought for their children to be educated in public schools because of the discrimination they faced in previous. Laws and regulations are the outgrowth of such discrimination and the very reason why special education advocates continue to be influential today. Unfortunately, these mandates have grown to 209 in NYS, many procedural not instructional focused (results from court decisions) and have tied the hands of districts. The reality is that special education decisions made by IEP teams need to take into account instructional best practices as well as state regulations (including court decisions). If staff is not trained and cognizant of special education law, districts may be sued (i.e., procedural violation even if they are following “best practices” and producing results) and faced additional hearing costs.
In the article "Excellence versus Equity", the authors made the following comment that I agree with 100%: "High functioning educational systems that pay attention to needs of individuals students serve all children well. Therefore, it is NOT a decision about how to target scare resources to one specific subgroup at the expense of another". The whole premise of special education is on individuality and developing targeted interventions with measurable outcome. As educational leaders, we need to help our staff and parents not to compete with one another about “subgroup” are getting all the resources at the cost of another. What is ironic is that the reason why special education continues to maintain a large budget is because of the mandates and regulations. Will our neediest students continue to get the high quality services they need if districts no longer have to provide them? If there is a program/strategy that is evidenced-based and proven to work for a specific disability would a district set aside monies to train staff if they are not required to? Would this lead to more lawsuits? Jeff and Paul comment about the gifted students and not doing such a great job on the other side of the spectrum. I agree! What is the reason for this disparity? Could it be as what the authors of the “Excellence versus Equity” article commented “Federal government did not impose minimum standards of gifted education”. What many don’t realize is that gifted education falls under “Special Education” however there is less of a focus partial because it is not required.
I agree that reform is needed in special education but due to the complexities of this field, there are no easy answers. Special Education should not be viewed as the primary reason why districts are faced with today’s financial hardships (meaning just cut special education and all our problems will go away and the rest of the students will be better serviced with the additional monies available) just as teachers alone are the cause of our failing schools (and we should not link their evaluations with state tests). Special Education like all other departments need to make some difficult decisions when it comes to costs (look to deliver services more wisely and maximize existing staff’s expertise/collaboration) but until the state reduces the mandates…we are obligated to meet them. This is the ugly truth. We do not have a choice as I share with many general education teachers who think it is ok to pick and choose what accommodations on a student’s IEP to follow. From my perspective, the most costly (in dollars as well as time) aspect of special education that needs to be reduced is litigations. This alone will save millions and will facilitate the mindset change from “compliance- driven” to “instructional-driven”.

Saturday, November 26, 2011

www.educationnext.org Equity versus excellence and the talented youth 2011

www.educationnext.org Equity versus excellence and the talented youth 2011
     Schnur and Wyner cite (PISA) to validate their claim that we have performance gaps for our students at all levels of achievement relative to their peers internationally.  They further go on to say that “U.S. students perform well below the standard of readiness for college and/or careers, regardless of where they fall on the achievement continuum” (p. 48).  The NYS Common Core Standards will hopefully address the needs of all students regardless of whether they are comprised of the talented tenth.  I have attached an up-to-date power point presentation which informs the reader of the implementation of the Common Core.  F:\NYS CCSS Presentation.ppt  
     Their four suggestions for changing an entire educational system may be a “stretch,” but it’s worth exploring and studying.  The first - all districts report student performance - and calculate achievement gaps - using rigorous, internationally benchmark standards will be challenging regardless of what the international benchmarks are. Secondly, it is sad to know that access to rigorous coursework in unevenly distributed across American high schools.  We really need to be consistent with our course offerings to provide equity across the spectrum.  Third, stagnation at any level serves no purpose whatsoever.  We need on-going SD to maintain the momentum in devising a rich curriculum for all students.  Finally, educational focus is an on-going dilemma.   What is good for one may not be good for others. 
     Hoogeneen (2011) prepared a commentary on F. Gagné and his suggestion for a well thought-out and elaborated (Academic) Talent Development [(A)TD] model, based on his differentiated Model of Giftedness and Talent (DMGT). One of its goals is to offer opportunities to all students. In this article, Hoogeneen states that maybe it is time to concentrate less on the gifted and more on offering better education to all students, including those who need a more challenging curriculum.  The author clearly elaborates to say that gurus such as Renzulli, Reis, and Borland would agree with this concept; however, the success will depend on the professionalism of those who decide who shall participate, and of those who are to apply it.
      I tend to disagree what Epstein and Pianko state that “one major drawback is that our most able students are not so much “shortchanged” as they are ignored” (p.50).  The most able student is the individual who tend to display exemplary motivation to achieve.  Student motivation should play into this.  Samuelson (2010) elaborates on the need for student motivation. 
     Concluding thoughts would solidify the need for the Common Core as stated in my opening.  We as educators need to be diligent and open to any suggestions to address the needs of all students.    

Friday, November 25, 2011

NYS Commission on Property Tax Relief

http://www.cptr.state.ny.us/propertyTaxCap/CPTRFactSheet_SpecialEd_Final_20081229.pdf   
      In response to the 12/29/08 NYSC on Property Tax Relief on Improving Special Education,  it was interesting to note that as of 2007, New York State has an additional 204 special education mandates that clarify or exceed federal mandates.  These unfunded mandates pose many discussions for schools boards across the country, thus creating hardships for districts around budget season.  I agree that special education reform is needed; however, we must never lose our focus on what is best for the child, no matter what the cost.  As a classroom teacher, I can assure you that that no child likes to be labeled  “special ed;” as a result, the general education environment should be enhanced to provide a positive learning experience for all.  The article concluded by identifying problems and offers solutions to improving special education.       
    On pages 82 through 84 of the final report to then Governor Paterson, the commission identified several remedies for strengthening educational services in general education.  RTI has been one initiative that has proven to be effective in many schools districts.  RTI ensures that services are available to more students, and would reduce classification.  The Commission recommends reducing litigation costs by promoting alternative dispute resolutions, removing a hearing lawyer in the dispute process, shifting the  burden of proof in hearings, and shortening the statute of limitations for non-approved private school reimbursement cases.  One would have to agree that these recommendations are valid. 
     Finally, I  was particularly intrigued that the Commission recommends school districts increase collaboration in providing services.  Just the three recommendations can save a district a tremendous amount of money when they have to prepare budgets.  Just the mention of facilitating a school district consortium to provide local alternatives to out-of-district placement, sharing out-of-district transportation and an increase interagency collaboration to provide efficient regional delivery of emotional and psychiatric treatment makes sound financial sense.  Only time will tell.                                                                                                                                    

    

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Equity vs. Excellence and the 'Talented Tenth': Which Boats Should We Lift?

-- With financial resources continuing to shrink, the high cost of special education is under increased scrutiny.  While many assert that current programming is well worth the cost, the call for reform is widespread, as illustrated in the following:

http://www.cptr.state.ny.us/propertyTaxCap/CPTRFactSheet_SpecialEd_Final_20081229.pdf

http://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2011/05/25/32futures.h30.html?tkn=OWQFPVSrPGFvRv6ozami39O9Qe7rSrXJmoJ1&intc=es 


-- While ruling on the side of parental reimbursement for private school placement in 2009, even members of the Supreme Court were somewhat in disagreement, with some justices noting the burden of the 'immense expense' of special education costs on school budgets:

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/23/education/23special.html?emc=eta1   


-- At the same time, there are those who make the case that the high cost of educating special needs students is at the expense of our most capable learners.  They claim that these high achieving students are being shortchanged at a time when their talents are vital to the nation's future economic stability and prosperity:

educationnext.org/files/ednext_20113_forum.pdf

-- With limited resources,  public education can no longer 'have it all'.  Some have suggested that the allocation of financial resources be guided by the use of a cost-benefit matrix: 




As we consider the allocation of resources in support of the 'instructional core',  there are difficult policy choices to be made.

Your thoughts?





Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Regional Collective Bargaining

Jim, I agree with you about exploring the benefits of regional collective bargaining. It would require a higher level of coordination and collaboration across communities with varied interests. If collective bargaining is viewed as a collaborative effort on behalf of the students focusing on improving working conditions for teachers to reach targeted goals versus a "competitive game" of what we can get from the system....it can work. Unfortunately, I do believe regulations will have to be put into place requiring districts to conduct business differently. It might be worthwhile for school leaders who are part of regional consortiums to begin the discussions now and come up with some viable solutions before they are mandated on us.... In order to increase the possibility for success, this concept needs to be started by district and union leaders, taking into consideration the necessary conditions (i.e., trust) for effective collaboration to occur....