Schnur and Wyner cite (PISA) to validate their claim that we have performance gaps for our students at all levels of achievement relative to their peers internationally. They further go on to say that “U.S. students perform well below the standard of readiness for college and/or careers, regardless of where they fall on the achievement continuum” (p. 48). The NYS Common Core Standards will hopefully address the needs of all students regardless of whether they are comprised of the talented tenth. I have attached an up-to-date power point presentation which informs the reader of the implementation of the Common Core. F:\NYS CCSS Presentation.ppt
Their four suggestions for changing an entire educational system may be a “stretch,” but it’s worth exploring and studying. The first - all districts report student performance - and calculate achievement gaps - using rigorous, internationally benchmark standards will be challenging regardless of what the international benchmarks are. Secondly, it is sad to know that access to rigorous coursework in unevenly distributed across American high schools. We really need to be consistent with our course offerings to provide equity across the spectrum. Third, stagnation at any level serves no purpose whatsoever. We need on-going SD to maintain the momentum in devising a rich curriculum for all students. Finally, educational focus is an on-going dilemma. What is good for one may not be good for others.
Hoogeneen (2011) prepared a commentary on F. Gagné and his suggestion for a well thought-out and elaborated (Academic) Talent Development [(A)TD] model, based on his differentiated Model of Giftedness and Talent (DMGT). One of its goals is to offer opportunities to all students. In this article, Hoogeneen states that maybe it is time to concentrate less on the gifted and more on offering better education to all students, including those who need a more challenging curriculum. The author clearly elaborates to say that gurus such as Renzulli, Reis, and Borland would agree with this concept; however, the success will depend on the professionalism of those who decide who shall participate, and of those who are to apply it.
I tend to disagree what Epstein and Pianko state that “one major drawback is that our most able students are not so much “shortchanged” as they are ignored” (p.50). The most able student is the individual who tend to display exemplary motivation to achieve. Student motivation should play into this. Samuelson (2010) elaborates on the need for student motivation.
Concluding thoughts would solidify the need for the Common Core as stated in my opening. We as educators need to be diligent and open to any suggestions to address the needs of all students.
No comments:
Post a Comment