Please read, comment as related to course content and public education in general, citing references where possible. [Minimum of 3 posts each. Individual personal reflections due (via email) by October 4th.]
'Charter Schools Tied to Turkey Grow in Texas'. New York Times. June 6, 2011.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/07/education/07charter.html?_r=2&emc=eta1
A few comments to clarify the intent of this post and, hopefully, to spark the conversation:
ReplyDelete-- The point of sharing this article is to raise the issue of publicly funded charter schools, in general, as well as potential concerns about the expenditure of taxpayer dollars to privately funded corporations. What are the advantages/disadvantages and potential impacts on public education? (Please don't be too concerned with the detailed background of Cosmos, unless that interests you, in favor of focusing on the issue of charter schools, and their potential impact on publicly funded education.)
--in reviewing the article, I suggest that you browse through the reader comments (this one got a great deal of attention!) as a means to better understand the range of opinions on this controversial issue. What is your reaction?
-- You also might want to do some other reading on this issue, referencing that in your comments.
-- Finally, I suggest that you view Harmony's website. What are your thoughts?
Okay, bloggers....go!!
After reading the NY Times article (June 6, 2011), Charter Schools Tied to Turkey Grow in Texas I was left wondering HOW this development occurred so quickly under the influence and dominance of Fethullah Gulen (charismatic Turkish preacher of a moderate brand of Islam whose devotees have built a worldwide religious, social and nationalistic movement in his name) followers. The facts provided, particularly those that pertained to contracting bids approved to build “Harmony Schools”, clearly depict companies connected to the Cosmos Foundation (charter school operator founded a decade ago by a group of professional and businessmen from Turkey.) were hired over those companies having no affiliations. Out of 35 contracts (worth $82 million) all but 3 (worth $1.5 million) went to Turkish-owned businesses. These contractors also supplied a variety of other services including breakfast and lunch to many of the Harmony Schools. Hundreds of teachers and administrators were imported from Turkey, many with no prior teaching experience. Furnishings were/are imported from Turkey. The majority of teachers and principals are Turkish men. As a matter of fact, one Turkish man (Dr. Soner Tarim) is the superintendent of THIRTY THREE Harmony Schools in Texas. Subsidized trips are encouraged to Turkey. Foundations (Raindrop Foundation) linked to Harmony Schools help pay for politicians’ trips to Turkey. HOW could all of this have happened? …(and still happening!) Will this serve as an example for other powerful and influential groups to get in on the action? Will this be the course for future Charter Schools in the US?
ReplyDeleteOn Harmony’s web page, the schools are described as, “high performing K-12 college prep charter schools” where “the college acceptance rate is 100% with a 0% drop out rate.” The site goes on to describe its vision: “to lead students into the world as productive and responsible citizens…even Nobel laureates.” The schools claim a student/faculty ration of 11:1. (www.harmonytx.org/about/). Newsweek even listed 2 Harmony Schools in their Top Ten Miracle Schools. This all sounds too good to be true, but certainly attractive! I think about the families that would immediately be drawn to this “miracle”. Are they taking the advertising at face value? Are they doing any research on their own to find out more.
According to retired teacher, Donna Garner, the “Gulen-Turkish-Cosmos Foundation-Harmony Charter Schools” are NOT really “miracle schools” (Harmony Charter Schools- Not Really “Miracle Schools”, 11/2011). The successful test scores claimed are due to the absence of monitors during state tests. Over half of the initial student enrollment leaves eventually, basically “weeding out” the weak. She jokingly remarks, “Perhaps the people who run Newsweek have taken too many free trips to Turkey.”
Will the rich and influential be able to so easily gain control of the development and growth of Charter Schools? It is very clear this is the case in Texas.
Some interesting points raised by this article (NY Times, June 6, 2011, Charter Schools Tied to Turkey Grow in Texas). The Harmony Public schools website http://www.harmonytx.org/about/faq/ states that “Harmony was established by a group of graduate students at Texas A&M University, who, after working as after-school tutors, realized the need for advanced math and science education in Texas. There are no ties of any kind to any religious movement.” I found this interesting as it curiously does not state its connection to Turkey.
ReplyDeleteThe point mentioned by Monique relating to Turkish businesses being awarded contracts to provide services for these schools is also interesting. Is this concern based on xenophobia, as the article states, or a genuine concern about operations? My guess is a little of both. I also could not stop thinking about Diane Ravitch’s comments regarding charter schools we viewed in class. Some of these points were stated in the New York Review of Books’ review of The Myth of Charter Schools by Diane Ravitch, November, 11, 2010. http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2010/nov/11/myth-charter-schools/?page=1
Ravitch argues that “charter schools are promoted not as ways to collaborate with public schools but as competitors that will force them to get better or go out of business.” Ravitch talks about the charter schools need for good test scores could cause a denial or expulsion of students “who might pull down their scores.” I am not sure if this is true of Harmony, but it makes you think about its acknowledgment by Newsweek. On the other hand, I do not want to condemn Harmony without all of the facts.
Flood of Turkish Teachers Prompts Investigation- World Net Daily Exclusive
ReplyDeleteMichael Carl (April 19, 2011)
Further investigation reveals that the operations of Fethullah Gulen “reportedly are now under investigation for visa fraud”. A parent became “curious” over teacher qualifications in these charter schools and as a result received information that there was indeed, an alleged fraud case.
“There are more than 100 facilities in 27 states now, the result of the work of Gulen, who lives in a heavily guarded compound near Saylorsburg, Pa.” Quite a contrast from his statement in the first article we read from the NY Times, Charter Schools Tied to Turkey’s Gulen Movement Grow in Texas. “His only possessions, he said, were a blanket, some bed sheets and a few prized books.” My guess is those books are REALLY expensive or something is terribly wrong.
Contributing editor, Paul Williams explains that Gulen left or “fled” Turkey in 1998 in order to “avoid prosecution from the secular government at that time; he wanted to set up an Islamic government”. Williams went on to say, “We have tens of thousands of teachers that are unemployed, and then Gulen for his schools imports thousands of teachers into this country.” A private investigator (not identified) agreed with Williams’ findings stating, “The Gulen movement has brought in over 1,000 teachers in the United States since 2001”.
The H1-B visa “is for people with expertise in specific fields”. Williams explains that teachers imported by Gulen do not have “the required specific course of higher education.” Also, few people in immigration and naturalization understand Turkish and “they’re not qualified to look into educational backgrounds of the people he (Gulen) is bringing in.” Another interesting finding from Williams is that “many of the principals and administrators will deny knowledge of Fethullah Gulen”. However, within days evidence and conversations proved that “everyone in Turkey knows who he is and has been influenced by him.”
I am so intrigued.
I was ambivalent to Stephanie Saul’s article Charter Schools Tied to Turkey Grow in Texas in the NY Times, June 6, 2011. Is the construction of so many of these Charter Schools a wonderful thing? Or is there a big corporation privatizing education in Texas? A clear advantage of Charter Schools in some cases is academic rigor and student success, but there is also clear inequity between the quality of these schools and some argue use of public funding - taking away from our own public schools system. I was suspect of Harmony/Cosmos, the Turkish influence, Mr. Gulen - and the interlocking web of networks within education these corporations manage – from Pre K – 12 to institutions of higher education. Are these schools that have been established throughout the state of Texas a well-intended, academic oasis for students – a “miracle” as Monique pointed out - of the organization? Or are the schools being used as a source for propaganda and fraudulent use of tax-payers money? It is certainly suspicious that “last year [Texas State Ed] took the unusual step of granting Harmony permission to open new schools outside the normal approval process.” And the article sheds doubt on the schools’ mission, saying “Ultimately, some scholars say, the schools are about more than just teaching schoolchildren. Hakan Yavuz, a Turkish-born assistant professor at the University of Utah’s Middle East Center, says he does not oppose the movement, though he is critical of what he calls its male domination and lack of transparency. In his view, the schools are the foundation for the movement’s attempts to grow in the United States. “The main purpose right now is to show the positive side of Islam and to make Americans sympathize with Islam,” Dr. Yavuz said.
ReplyDeleteThere are some astute comments posted at the end of this article – both in favor and against the schools. A common theme in some postings is that this article could touch off some major anti-Turkish and anti-Muslim sentiments, and that the author should have been more concerned about this. But several Harmony School parents also posted their praises for the academic strength of the schools and for the focus math and science, as well as on Turkish language and opportunity to study in Turkey.
This article is intriguing and presents major considerations for educational leaders as to the future of the Charter School movement, and how these schools are to be held accountable for not only academics, but management of finances, teacher recruitment and mission.
Interesting and insightful comments! For sure, this article makes clear, as Monique points out, that the ultimate control of charter schools remains uncertain. And then, of course, there's the question of whether any particular 'background influence' is appropriate...or not, especially in publicly funded schools, not to mention the questions of accountability, as referenced by Paul and Lisa.
ReplyDeleteOne thing is for sure: the movement is growing, as evidenced by NYS's recent award of RTTP money, referenced in the following NYSCOSS blog (the NYSCOSS site is a good resource, btw):
http://blog.nyscoss.org/2011/07/21/charter-schools-spreading-to-the-suburbs
There's so much still at issue. To me, among the most compelling questions are:
-- Especially in the midst of a crisis in school funding, what will be the net effect of public dollars being siphoned away from districts to charter schools?
-- One of the underlying principles of charter schools is that they have more freedom to be innovative and experimental. I'm all for that, though wonder why those same freedoms can't be offered to all public schools (which instead are being increasingly regulated)? To the contrary, it seems as if the vision for public schools is simultaneously moving in two opposing directions!
This is very interesting. It appears that the concept of charter schools can run counterproductive to the improvement of public schools. Lowry (http://blog.nyscoss.org/2011/07/21/charter-schools-spreading-to-the-suburbs/) points out that “Districts seldom realize anything close to dollar-for-dollar savings when students move to a charter school.” He also asks the question, “should there be a broader effort to ensure that all schools are giving students the education they will need to succeed in life beyond school?” It seems that this should be the focus, but is apparently getting lost in the charter school movement (“last year’s raising of the state’s charter school cap from 200 to 460” doesn’t help). The same counterproductive actions are felt by educators when they seem to be treated as the problem instead of as part of the solution. Some of the new mandates seem to work against the team mentality and stress the individual. This concept seems to mirror what is happening with charter schools. Interesting.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading an article, Fethulla Gulen: Infiltrating the U.S. Through Our Charter Schools (April 2009, www.actforamerica.org) I was troubled by most of what was written, in particular- “the Department of Homeland Security tried to deport him” (referring to Gulen).
ReplyDelete“… Fethullah Gulen, a Turkish imam who now lives in the United States. He fled Turkey in 1998 to avoid prosecution on charges that he was attempting to undermine Turkey’s secular government with the objective of establish an Islamic government. Since Gulen’s arrival here the Department of Homeland Security tried to deport him, but he successfully fought the effort in federal court because it was ruled he was an individual with “extraordinary ability in the field of education” – although he has no formal education training.”
I was also surprised to learn that Gulen has no formal education training, yet “he oversees a worldwide network of businesses, schools, foundations and media outlets, with an estimated budget of 25 billion dollars.”
I found this piece of the article alarming: (Gulen, 1999 sermon aired on Turkish TV)
“You must move in the arteries of the system without anyone noticing your existence until you reach all the power centers … until the conditions are ripe, they [the followers] must continue like this. If they do something prematurely, the world will crush our heads, and Muslims will suffer everywhere, like in the tragedies in Algeria, like in 1982 [in] Syria … like in the yearly disasters and tragedies in Egypt. The time is not yet right. You must wait for the time when you are complete and conditions are ripe, until we can shoulder the entire world and carry it.”
Another piece I found equally alarming:
“Our readers may be familiar with the numerous emails we have released regarding the operation of the Tarek ibn Zayed Academy (TiZA), a publicly funded charter school in Minnesota that is so blatantly Islamic in nature that the Minnesota Department of Education issued two citations against it and the ACLU is suing it. FGC schools appear to be very different, and reflect the Gulen’s exhortation to “move in the arteries of the system without anyone noticing your existence until you reach all the power centers…”
Is the Gulen movement sincere about education in the US? The more I read, the more I see red flags (waving!). Taxpayers’ money supports these Charter Schools that have obvious connections to the Gulen movement. Why was deportation even considered? Are we concerned over Gulen becoming a national security threat?
The article goes on to quote readers’ reactions:
“Anyone who thinks that Gulen's schools are just here to help educate our children is naive about how insidious and criminal their activities truly are. Their actions are far reaching and the United States government has not diligently investigated their actions.”
“I have to wonder if the reason the United States government has turned a blind eye to Gulen's schools' blatant disregard for civil rights (discrimination), money-laundering, and immigration fraud, is because of its desire to help facilitate Turkey's admission into the EU and its passage into Middle Eastern energy corridor.”
and finally:
“I find it a little more than ridiculous that such a huge number of Turkish academics would take it upon themselves to come to the U.S. just to improve our education system and that all of this is just a coincidence.”
I happen to agree. There is no “coincidence”.
Hi Folks,
ReplyDeleteI would like to begin my reflection by providing some context for charter schools: Although my history may be a bit imprecise, the current model of formalized American education has been in existence since the late 18th century. Relative to other fields (such as medicine), not much in education has changed.
Charter schools, or "schools of choice," are a relatively new idea (circa 1988). Given the relative infancy of charter schools, and the fact that there are likely no experts in our field who can claim to be the product of a charter school education, the model comes under a lot of scrutiny... and perhaps rightfully so.
Given that the traditional model of public school has been determined by many as inadequate, charter schools are an attempt at progress. While there may certainly be many flaws, I believe it is commendable that some folks are attempting to try something new and experimental. Imagine where the field of medicine would be today if it were not for Alfred Velpeau (he invented anesthesia in 1839).
Besides the infancy of charter schools, it is also important to remember that parents choose to send their children to these schools. In fact, according to Wikipedia, 59% of charter schools polled require a lottery for enrollment since the desire to attend exceeds the number of available seats.
With that backdrop, I would like to turn to the present case. Having read the article, Harmony's website and many of the public comments on this particular issue, I can see the outrage at what appears to be outright collusive behavior. I understand the frustration stemming from (whether it be perception or reality) a Gulen movement infiltrating schools. And, I can appreciate the overtone of anger and frustration expressed by many commentators regarding the lack of accountability and objective financial oversight.
But let's bring this back to what we learned in our first class. Sowell said, “Without scarcity there is no need to economize…” (p. 2). Charter schools are scarce, and you don’t have to send your children there. Let that sink in.
I look at the Harmony schools like one of at least four products sitting on a shelf (the other three being public schooling, private schooling and home schooling.) Texas, like anywhere else, is a competitive marketplace. If there were no value in the Harmony schools (real or perceived), parents would simply select a different item from the shelf. If enough people felt that the Harmony schools were not appropriate, the “brand” would wither and be discontinued. However, that does not appear to be the case… in fact it appears that the brand is gaining momentum and loyalty from American consumers.
All of the scrutiny concerning the processes involved in obtaining bids for construction and the nepotism around hiring teachers and administrators to run the schools is, in my opinion, completely understandable, yet completely invalid. Charter schools are commissioned as autonomous, and are therefore not intended to be subject to the same rules as public schools. I feel that the pervasive discomfort with this case is due to the fact that the Gulen schools do not behave like a public school should… but if it did wouldn’t it just be another public school?
It is no secret that Nike, inc. pays workers in third world countries fractions of pennies on the dollar to produce sneakers for consumption in the US, yet we sustain their operations by buying their shoes. In Texas, the Harmony schools are hiring Turkish contractors to build schools staffed by Turkish teachers and are perpetuating Gulen principles, yet parents are selecting these schools over other available options. If people do not like the movement of Gulen schools, they should stop sending their children. Once supply exceeds demand, the market will correct itself.
In the words of Sowell, once again, “But life does not ask us what we want. It presents us with options. Economics is one of the ways of trying to make the most of these options.” (p. 7).
Jeff
In response to Joanne's comment::
ReplyDelete-- Especially in the midst of a crisis in school funding, what will be the net effect of public dollars being siphoned away from districts to charter schools?
While I don't have a direct answer to this question, I think it is all relative. As more charter schools open, sure they get public funding, but they are also using that money to serve the children who will now attend their schools. The result is that public schools should need less money to operate since they are not servicing those children in exodus. I sense that this reality is often lost in the debate.
Charter Schools Spreading to Affluent Suburbs, New York Times, July 21, 2011
ReplyDeleteWill these “boutique schools” REALLY drive competition enough to “impel district schools to improve?”
Personally, I would love to see this investment of time and money brought back into the public school system. Give the public schools more flexibility! Yes, Charter Schools do offer parents/caretakers a choice- but as we read information about the Harmony Schools, students that do not perform are asked to leave. I would assume those students are enrolled back into the public school, possibly from where they first started and are probably not too happy. Now the public school is taking in these “drop outs” that really don’t want to be there- not a great recipe for successful and motivated learning!
Don’t we also need to be concerned about the issue of certification and the quality of certified teachers in Charter Schools? Perhaps that is why students are asked to leave. Those “teaching” were never trained in dealing with differentiation, classroom management and appropriate learning strategies.
This article was an interesting read. The comments from readers of the article were mixed. I do agree with the comments that the tone of the article leaned towards "Anti-Muslim" and tapping into the national anxiety of the Islam movement in this country. Based on the information presented in the article, there was still a lot of ambiguity about the schools that raises concerns about their religious affiliations and the level of influence. Harmony schools make it very clear that they do not teach religion but many of their after-school and community supports are being run by such religious agencies. I also found the angry comment from a parent whose son attended a Harmony school and was dissatisfied by the "academic tracking" that was taking place (the course catalogue clearly stated that students are placed in specific groups based on ability levels and in the lower grades students are in self-contained classes).
ReplyDeleteAfter reading the article and reviewing Harmony's website, nowhere did I see evidence that would support that these charter schools provide a better education per se (no research or statistics of how their students were performing). I found many of the highlights of Harmony Schools are "best practices" that we have been discussing to restructure our public schools. I found it very interesting that they describe their schools as promoting a "culture of collaboration and distributed leadership. Their focus is on the three big R’s: Rigor, Relevance, and Relationships. I can see the benefit that charter schools have in respect to having greater autonomy with their budgets and academic day. Some individuals appear to believe charter schools resembles the best features of public schools without the influences of the unions and boards. However, I found it interesting that Harmony Schools is governed by a not-for-profit (not nonprofit, still reaping benefits) with a Board of Directors. Previously, I worked for a not-for-profit servicing underprivileged students in low-performing schools. I know firsthand the freedoms of working for such an agency but there were two distinct differences: 1.) Monies came from private sectors (fundraising) and grants but taxpayers monies. 2.) We worked in close partnership with public schools and were housed in their buildings. It does not appear the federal governments has learned from the mistakes of the past (to avoid improper use of public funds) by not holding these schools (paid by taxpayers) to the same standards and regulations for academic/fiscal accountability as they do for public schools. It is my opinion that the charter schools movement is more politically ($$$) than anything else to reroute monies to fund the ultimate goal – privatizing American Schools. I want to be an optimist and believe that the government is using charter schools as a “pilot” to show what changes need to be done for the betterment of our public schools but this movement appears to be at odds in so many ways to work together with us. Many actions taken around the charter school movement does not make sense but I believe there is a hidden agenda that is the driving force. That is why it is so important for us to fight for what is right for our children and take the road less traveled at times…. I plan to read more about charter schools (one commenter recommended “White Flight”) because some are doing wonderful work with our neediest students. It is important to remember that not all public schools function as our schools and some children are suffering due to this inequity leading more & more parents to be very attractive to the notion of “school choice”.
I believe part of the solution leading to a successful public education is involving the FAMILY. I came across a reaction to Charter Schools by Malik Green, the author of "The Black Print-Black America's Blueprint for Achieving Wealth, Prosperity and Respect"
ReplyDeleteHe states, “The main reason why many African American parents are proponents of charter schools is statistical data; though inconclusive, shows that perform better than public schools. Charter schools were initially created in to serve the poorest of the low-income students, which is another way to describe many African Americans and other people of color.”
I found this interesting: “In reality, however, charter schools only accept small percentages of low-income kids. Also, the very rarely accept extremely high risk, high need, or challenging students. This may be the reason for their great, though questionable, statistical numbers. Many people look at the children who are benefiting from charter school and neglect to mention the hopelessness of those who are not able to attend a charter school.”
“Our tax dollars are used to fund public schools. The administrators of these schools, such as, the Board of Education, community school boards, and Parent Teacher Associations are either incompetent or uncaring. If all three of these bodies were doing their job the right way, there would be no need for charter schools.”
I believe ALL families, particularly those in the minority must get involved with their child’s education. Malik Green goes on to say, “African Americans must become proactive in regards to the goings-on in their communities. Stand up and fight for what is right. Stop listening to the phony politicians and others who are selling us a bag of bones in regards to our children’s well being. If billions of dollars are allocated every year towards education, how come our children are failing? Is it because of incompetence, greed, lack of accountability, or is it the fact that those who are supposed to look out for us don’t really give a damn about us.”
“Let's rethink this charter school thing, because it is not all that it seems to be.”
Are we (teachers and administrators) recognizing the importance of family involvement? Why is there such dissatisfaction towards the public school system? Are we reaching out to parents/caretakers and motivating families to be involved with their children’s learning? I believe these are concerns we are totally overlooking.