EmergingIssues

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Equity vs. Excellence and the 'Talented Tenth': Which Boats Should We Lift?

-- With financial resources continuing to shrink, the high cost of special education is under increased scrutiny.  While many assert that current programming is well worth the cost, the call for reform is widespread, as illustrated in the following:

http://www.cptr.state.ny.us/propertyTaxCap/CPTRFactSheet_SpecialEd_Final_20081229.pdf

http://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2011/05/25/32futures.h30.html?tkn=OWQFPVSrPGFvRv6ozami39O9Qe7rSrXJmoJ1&intc=es 


-- While ruling on the side of parental reimbursement for private school placement in 2009, even members of the Supreme Court were somewhat in disagreement, with some justices noting the burden of the 'immense expense' of special education costs on school budgets:

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/23/education/23special.html?emc=eta1   


-- At the same time, there are those who make the case that the high cost of educating special needs students is at the expense of our most capable learners.  They claim that these high achieving students are being shortchanged at a time when their talents are vital to the nation's future economic stability and prosperity:

educationnext.org/files/ednext_20113_forum.pdf

-- With limited resources,  public education can no longer 'have it all'.  Some have suggested that the allocation of financial resources be guided by the use of a cost-benefit matrix: 




As we consider the allocation of resources in support of the 'instructional core',  there are difficult policy choices to be made.

Your thoughts?





16 comments:

  1. In response to: http://www.cptr.state.ny.us/propertyTaxCap/CPTRFactSheet_SpecialEd_Final_20081229.pdf

    In order to address the financial issues Special Education has faced and is still struggling with, one must also be reminded of the educational reform, Response to Intervention (RtI). The roots of the concept of responsiveness or Response to Intervention (Rtl) are an attempt to find the best way to educate children by adjusting pedagogical strategies based on student patterns of responses (Grigorenko, 2009).

    In my opinion, this is “easier said than done!”

    Core components of Rtl include high-quality classroom instruction, universal screening, continuous progress monitoring, research-based interventions, and fidelity of instructional interventions (Jiménez, 2010). Perhaps the success of RtI would lead to fewer students requiring Special Education (costly) services.

    RtI assumes that students will no longer have to “wait to fail” to receive help and it may prevent the over-identification of students for Special Education (Jiménez, 2010). Logically, with less students identified, this would address the financial issues of Special Education by reducing costs.

    As a classroom teacher (Tier One provider), with dual certification (inclusive of Special Education), RtI DOES make sense. However, I needed to do most of the research to answer my questions and concerns over the change in instruction, monitoring, interventions and instruction required to make RtI successful.

    There will absolutely be more responsibilities expected from the classroom teacher, as far as progress monitoring and applying current research-based interventions. Yes, of course this makes sense, but appropriate training and at the very least, an explanation of what RtI actually is, are required.

    Every student counts in a classroom. An effective teacher will make sure of this. Every student should be receiving the very best instruction, monitoring and interventions to address specific strengths and weaknesses. RtI is a positive reform that has the potential to guide classroom teachers towards the belief of PROGRESS for all.

    RtI has the potential for reducing the numbers of identified students in Special Education, thereby reducing costs. However, RtI has to be “done right”!

    ReplyDelete
  2. While it is obvious that there is a significant issue with spending in Special Education, I had to keep myself from contrasting the results of the PISA study referenced in the Equity Versus Excellence article and the Improving Special Education Fact Sheet prepared by the state.

    Even thought the messages given in both of these articles are alarming (e.g. the US's poor rankings in ELA, Math and Science compared with other nations, and NYS's exorbitant spending in Special Education) we cannot necessarily assume that the two are related. What I mean is that the state data is just that... specific to NY, whereas the PISA results are international. I wonder if one were to disaggregate the PISA results by region, what they would find. Are districts who spend such large amounts on Special Education producing students who, overall, perform higher on such measures?

    The other obvious issue with making such comparisons is the frequent oversight that other nations do not test students who are identified as special education; therefore there is no rational basis on which to compare or judge.

    ReplyDelete
  3. After reading the Times article about the Supreme Court decision, I find it most alarming that a decision which has such significant financial impact (i.e. requiring districts to reimburse for private schools) could be passed without regard for the district's ability to pay.

    With already insufficient funding, ever increasing accountability and testing requirements, this additional burden on public schools will likely cause the an education implosion similar to the one found in the economy.

    Simply, it is not sustainable to continue to spend more than you have. If there were an international raking on this metric, I am sure the US would be number 1!

    ReplyDelete
  4. http://www.cptr.state.ny.us/propertyTaxCap/CPTRFactSheet_SpecialEd_Final_20081229.pdf
    In response to the 12/29/08 NYSC on Property Tax Relief on Improving Special Education, it was interesting to note that as of 2007, New York State has an additional 204 special education mandates that clarify or exceed federal mandates. These unfunded mandates pose many discussions for schools boards across the country, thus creating hardships for districts around budget season. I agree that special education reform is needed; however, we must never lose our focus on what is best for the child, no matter what the cost. As a classroom teacher, I can assure you that that no child likes to be labeled “special ed;” as a result, the general education environment should be enhanced to provide a positive learning experience for all. The article concluded by identifying problems and offers solutions to improving special education.
    On pages 82 through 84 of the final report to then Governor Paterson, the commission identified several remedies for strengthening educational services in general education. RTI has been one initiative that has proven to be effective in many schools districts. RTI ensures that services are available to more students, and would reduce classification. The Commission recommends reducing litigation costs by promoting alternative dispute resolutions, removing a hearing lawyer in the dispute process, shifting the burden of proof in hearings, and shortening the statute of limitations for non-approved private school reimbursement cases. One would have to agree that these recommendations are valid.
    Finally, I was particularly intrigued that the Commission recommends school districts increase collaboration in providing services. Just the three recommendations can save a district a tremendous amount of money when they have to prepare budgets. Just the mention of facilitating a school district consortium to provide local alternatives to out-of-district placement, sharing out-of-district transportation and an increase interagency collaboration to provide efficient regional delivery of emotional and psychiatric treatment makes sound financial sense. Only time will tell.

    ReplyDelete
  5. While I am in agreement and full support that all children deserve a proper education, the 2009 ruling of the Supreme Court can be troublesome. Where are the school districts going to get funds to provide parents of special education students reimbursement for private school tuition? Clearly the federal and local government need to share this responsibility with an increase of federal and state aid to schoool districts. I agree with Jeff's statement regarding the decision without any regard as to the district's ability or inability to pay. In the meantime, RTI and enhanced regular education classes seem to be the right fit.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The New York State Commission’s report in 2008 on Property Tax Relief – Improving Special Education (http://www.cptr.state.ny.us/propertyTaxCap/CPTRFactSheet_SpecialEd_Final_20081229.pdf) makes clear that our State is in need of Special Education reform that can address the allocation of funding for programs and services for this population – one of the highest per pupil cost in the States – and seek relief from State mandates that can exceed what is required at the federal level. The fact sheet shows the money spent per pupil in the State and that New York “ranked 38th in 2005 in successfully exiting the special education system with a diploma”. How can we justify the money being spent on special education programs and services with such a rate of success? How can we ensure better outcomes? Are we using the right strategies? I was most in agreement with an approach of improving general education initiatives, decreasing classifications and an emphasis on outcomes versus focus on meeting State regulations. How can we ensure quality special education in our districts while cutting the cost to do so? As pointed out by Jim, collaboration of services is referred to as a strategy in the fact sheet. But beyond the combination of services between schools/districts, I think a key is reflection on practice. How do we know we are using best practices? The State can also offer relief to districts by providing flexibility in regulations and as the fact sheet points out focusing more on outcome assessments.

    ReplyDelete
  7. www.educationnext.org Equity versus excellence and the talented youth 2011
    Schnur and Wyner cite (PISA) to validate their claim that we have performance gaps for our students at all levels of achievement relative to their peers internationally. They further go on to say that “U.S. students perform well below the standard of readiness for college and/or careers, regardless of where they fall on the achievement continuum” (p. 48). The NYS Common Core Standards will hopefully address the needs of all students regardless of whether they are comprised of the talented tenth. I have attached an up-to-date power point presentation which informs the reader of the implementation of the Common Core. F:\NYS CCSS Presentation.ppt
    Their four suggestions for changing an entire educational system may be a “stretch,” but it’s worth exploring and studying. The first - all districts report student performance - and calculate achievement gaps - using rigorous, internationally benchmark standards will be challenging regardless of what the international benchmarks are. Secondly, it is sad to know that access to rigorous coursework in unevenly distributed across American high schools. We really need to be consistent with our course offerings to provide equity across the spectrum. Third, stagnation at any level serves no purpose whatsoever. We need on-going SD to maintain the momentum in devising a rich curriculum for all students. Finally, educational focus is an on-going dilemma. What is good for one may not be good for others.
    Hoogeneen (2011) prepared a commentary on F. Gagné and his suggestion for a well thought-out and elaborated (Academic) Talent Development [(A)TD] model, based on his differentiated Model of Giftedness and Talent (DMGT). One of its goals is to offer opportunities to all students. In this article, Hoogeneen states that maybe it is time to concentrate less on the gifted and more on offering better education to all students, including those who need a more challenging curriculum. The author clearly elaborates to say that gurus such as Renzulli, Reis, and Borland would agree with this concept; however, the success will depend on the professionalism of those who decide who shall participate, and of those who are to apply it.
    I tend to disagree what Epstein and Pianko state that “one major drawback is that our most able students are not so much “shortchanged” as they are ignored” (p.50). The most able student is the individual who tend to display exemplary motivation to achieve. Student motivation should play into this. Samuelson (2010) elaborates on the need for student motivation.
    Concluding thoughts would solidify the need for the Common Core as stated in my opening. We as educators need to be diligent and open to any suggestions to address the needs of all students.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The 2009 Supreme Court decision presents an even bigger budget concern for districts now responsible for reimbursement of private tuition costs for special needs students when appropriate accommodations cannot be made. Such uncertainty, as Jeff points out, is simply unsustainable for schools. Being proactive could yield a better outcome versus reactive to the decision. How can we improve services in schools - to address all students’ needs? How can we keep from special ed students needing private programs and services to supplement instruction? An April 2009 article in Ed Week, Justices Weigh Special Education Tuition Reimbursements discusses the need for consideration of a public school plan before a district is required to pay private tuition costs. Such consideration seems an equitable approach to this issue. "What's wrong with 10 days?" the chief justice said to David B. Salmons, in reference to a suggested minimum time for families to try out an IEP before pulling their children from the public schools. "It's a big expense you are asking the school district to incur, that will take away funds from other programs. And all they are saying is, give it a try for 10 days, and if it doesn't work out, then you can go." (http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/school_law/2009/04/justices_weigh_special_educati.html)

    ReplyDelete
  9. The fact sheet on Special Education http://www.cptr.state.ny.us/propertyTaxCap/CPTRFactSheet_SpecialEd_Final_20081229.pdf
    shows that there is an issue with Special Education spending. However, to compare different student needs and expect to come up with some sort of equal spending is wrong. The Equity Versus Excellence article points out that we should be getting better results from our spending. I agree with Jeff’s comments. It is difficult to compare the United States internationally if other nations have different systems. Other nations, who do not test Special Education students, would get results that cannot be compared.

    Also, the needs of students differ and sometimes a student needs a different approach than others. If we are keeping all students in the same system (college bound) we should expect to pay more for some students. Rick Wormeli, wrote a book called Fair Isn’t Always Equal. Its title says it all. We cannot expect that every student’s needs would cost the same. If fair was equal than we all would be without a job, as a book of rules and cost measures would have all the answers. To follow a high benefit, low cost model would discriminate against the students that need more. This refers to all students. Some students need more because they are advanced, not because they are Special Education students. I do agree, however, that finding more efficient ways to run programs should always be sought. RtI, as mentioned, should be a focus.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The New York Times article http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/23/education/23special.html?emc=eta1
    is interesting. The passing of Supreme Court decisions is comparable to unfunded Federal mandates. It is quite a conflict of thought to institute a Tax Cap and pass unfunded mandates (decisions) at the same time. If the Federal government truly wants to reduce spending and find efficiencies, then the Federal government should fund all private school placements. Think about it. Would the Federal government/Supreme Court pass these laws if it was required to pay for it? I wonder what the system (red tape) would look like if the Federal government was responsible to pay for private education placements. Just a thought.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Regarding Monique's comments about RTI:

    I look at RTI is a great way of boosting support for those children who may otherwise "fall through the cracks" by providing earlier and therefore less intensive intervention. However, I do not believe that RTI is the solution to or even comes close to addressing the money spent on children requiring special education.

    If you think back to our discussion on class size where we detailed the actual costs associated with hiring a teacher, try and imagine the student who is placed in a self-contained class (with 5-6 other students). In addition to the classroom teacher, there are likely several one-one assistants in that class. Such students may also receive speech and language, occupational therapy, and assistive technology. When you add it up, this student may cost the district 5-6 times what a general education student would cost to educate per year (per-pupil expenditure of $100,000+ versus PPE of $22,000 for an average student in Eastchester.) Imagine that over the course of 13 years... This one child could cost the district over 1.5 million dollars! As schools do a great job providing appropriate services to students with such significant needs, they earn excellent reputations for their special education programs, drawing other families who have children with special needs.

    Besides the staffing costs, there are also administrative costs associated with IEP reviews and tri-annuals, assessments, and often negotiations for extraneous expenses (in my former district we were required to install a galvanized steel slide on the playground because a child with a cochlear implant could not use the plastic slide because it caused static electricity.)

    I think Paul's comment about "fairness versus equity" is right on, and I agree that we are probably not doing a great service to those students at the other end spectrum: (those who are performing 2 standard deviations to the right of the mean). In fact, most districts have abolished gifted and talented programs (although I am not commenting on the merits for or against such programs at this point).

    ReplyDelete
  12. According to the New York State Commission on Property Tax Relief, Improving Special Education (2008), “We, as a State, must do a better job of providing in the general education setting the extra help and other supportive services that parents demand and children with milder issues need. Classifying students into special education is not only more costly, but more restrictive and potentially less conducive to a student’s success.”

    All children need and deserve differentiated support. This can be difficult and often problematic. Operating a classroom effectively and efficiently can be like running a 10-ring circus. For example, an average 4th grade classroom could have students reading at the first grade level to a middle school level. The range of behaviors can be just as wide.

    I believe the key to effective teaching is certainly content knowledge, but even more importantly, classroom management. If teachers are to do a better job in providing the extra help and services in the classroom to ALL students (low and high range of learners) then colleges and universities offering degrees in teaching need to update and improve their programs.

    As stated in: A Fact Sheet Prepared by the Staff of the New York State Commission on Property Tax Relief, special education reform is needed because costs are too high. If indeed special education reform will save money in the long run, teachers need to be prepared to effectively manage inclusive classrooms. If this is not the case, and college education programs are not current where the focus needs to shift to dealing with reforms such as RtI, children will suffer academically and emotionally.

    ReplyDelete
  13. In reference to the article, “Excellence versus Equity” I do agree that “high functioning educational systems that pay attention to needs of individual students serve all children well.” However, with budget cuts, increasing numbers of students in classrooms, as well as the loss of support in the classroom (teaching assistants) this is becoming more and more of a challenge.

    As Nicole pointed out, “As educational leaders, we need to help our staff and parents not compete with one another about the subgroups that are getting all of the resources at the cost of another.” I agree with Nicole, however distribution of resources can often “look” unfair.

    I believe, as I am quite sure many people do, that fairness means paying attention to an individual’s needs and nurturing progress in EVERY student. The reality is- support does make a difference in the classroom. Inclusive classrooms often have support throughout the day where “non-inclusive” classrooms may have one 45-minute period or perhaps none at all. There are times when an inclusive classroom will have 2 teachers (classroom and special ed.), a teaching assistant and a student teacher (often assigned to inclusive classrooms). Compared to a non-inclusive classroom with no support, this certainly “looks” unfair. One also needs to remember that non-inclusive classrooms have students with a variety of needs as well.

    Jeff, Paul and Nicole mentioned the support (or lack of) for the gifted students. In a typical fourth grade non-inclusive classroom in White Plains, students can range from a DRA level of 18 to a level of 50 or higher. Without in-classroom support, effectively managing this diversity is critical (and challenging!). RtI reform reinforces this need to ensure everyone is managed/monitored efficiently and effectively. I believe teachers need improvement in the area of the management of a diverse classroom and more information on ways to successfully implement RtI. I believe leaders need to support professional development in this particular area.

    I think the general “rule of thumb” seems to be: do more with less. White Plains has created Intervention Blocks (I Block) to be an integral part of the day. During this 40 minute period that occurs at the same time for each grade, students will either go to: Reading, Special Ed, ELL or Enrichment support outside of the classroom. For example, in the fourth grade, every day from 11:20 to 12:00, students leave their classrooms to go to their designated support groups. Those students that do not receive Reading, Special Ed, ELL or Enrichment support are further divided into 5 groups: 2 lower (less than a DRA 38) with a focus on their specific needs (usually fluency and comprehension). The 3 remaining groups with a DRA 38 or higher participate in the Great Books reading program. Essentially, everyone is “pulled” for service to meet individual needs.

    By examining what programs and schedules work best for EVERY student is key. This also requires time and reflection from teachers and leaders working together. TIME??? Somehow, we need to find the time to do this.

    ReplyDelete
  14. In reply to Jim’s remark on saving school districts money, (“I was particularly intrigued that the Commission recommends school districts increase collaboration in providing services”), I totally agree. The sharing of out-of district transportation, as well as the increase in inter-agency collaboration makes so much sense.

    I would also love to see an increase in districts collaborating on “best practice”. I believe there is a wealth of information that can be shared. Recently, a colleague (Reading Specialist) and I presented to an audience of graduate students, teachers and administrators at the Learning Disabilities World Wide Conference held at Manhattanville. Our presentation was on what RtI “looks like” in the White Plains School District. The presentation resulted in a rich share of ideas with school districts all over Westchester County and some parts of New York City. Even though every district was at a different place in the implementation of RtI, everyone came away with new (and practical!) pieces of information. This “valuable” learning was all from the sharing and gathering of everyone’s expertise in the audience.

    Ideally, teachers and leaders should have more opportunities to work together within their own district, as well as other districts, for the purpose of discussing “best practice” and successful outcomes. How can we find the time and money to do this?

    ReplyDelete
  15. Providing programs and services to students should not need to be an either or situation - that one group should not benefit over another as presented in Excellence in Education. I agree. Schools should strive to provide learning experiences that accommodate all learners. Schools should ensure that all student populations receive equal opportunities for optimal learning experiences and instruction. But while such an approach seems most fair – and equitable, it’s not reality. Most schools cannot afford to provide specialized programs and services for all student groups, or to hire teachers to run them. So how do we develop all students? How do we provide for all learners? Maybe the question should be “why focus”? “Ultimately, America’s competitive advantage rests on a public education system that pushes beyond the limits of the “talented tenth” paradigm and fully develops the human capital of far more of our students.” Instead of trying to decide which student groups should receive additional funding, we should strive to accommodate all students by having teachers and pupil personnel trained to meet the wide ranging needs of the eclectic student populations found in schools. I agree with Nicole and Monique in saying that our focus should be on meeting the individual needs of every student, and that there should not be competition for funding between groups and subgroups of students. But, how can we make this goal a reality and realize a sense of “fiscal fairness” in our schools?

    ReplyDelete
  16. Lisa (along with the rest of our class) has some great points. One group should not benefit over another as presented in Excellence in Education. We seem to be spending much time, energy, and resources in order to make this happen. When one group gets an advantage, the other wants it evened out. Our system makes it difficult to achieve equality. I wonder if the new common core will help. If we concentrate on critical thinking as opposed to memorizing facts, perhaps the education provided to all groups will be more equitable. The mission statement listed on the site http://www.corestandards.org/ states:

    “The Common Core State Standards provide a consistent, clear understanding of what students are expected to learn, so teachers and parents know what they need to do to help them. The standards are designed to be robust and relevant to the real world, reflecting the knowledge and skills that our young people need for success in college and careers. With American students fully prepared for the future, our communities will be best positioned to compete successfully in the global economy.”

    These standards will also make it easier for our colleges to produce teachers ready to take on the challenges of educating our youth. I agree with Lisa, Monique, and Nicole regarding the need for our teachers to be prepared to individualize instruction to meet the needs of their students. The common core gives us a chance to re-train our veteran teachers and mold our future teachers to meet the needs of today’s students.

    We need to embrace the implementation of the Common Core State Standards as it will be a long time before we get an opportunity like this one. The problem that exists is that the benefit of the common core is overshadowed by the focus on school budgets (economy) and APPR process.

    ReplyDelete