I believe schools are forever changed. The public is demanding change (because of the personal tolls they face with the economy and the negative media of how schools are preparing students for the 21st Century) and the politicians are taking advantage of this "prime opportunity" to make drastic policy changes for various internal motives: cut costs because the national deficit, give more power back to the local agencies that govern schools, and most importantly influence the political front of how people vote and who is elected.
I personally believe that the attempts to limit the collective bargaining rights have credibility. I have witnessed firsthand how school leaders' hands are tied to make necessary changes (i.e., removing incompetent teachers, changing the school schedule) because of union contracts. I also hear too often from teachers that they would be happy to do something (i.e., stay late for a meeting, perform duties outside their schedule) but are pressured to comply with what the collective group has decided. I do understand the opinion from some that having teachers pay union dues obligates them to take certain actions (i.e., vote for a specific party). The reality is that we all are going to have to pay more for health insurance and we do need to reexamine how teachers are compensated to ensure fairness and take into consideration the current economic times. However, I do not support teachers having no due process rights, not having the ability to negotiate, and having politicians touch teachers’ pensions that they have earned and worked very hard to preserve.
Unions were put into place for "real" reasons and it is very likely teachers will be taken advantaged if certain agreements are not in place. If the focus is on student learning, both the union and district administration are usually able to come to some mutual agreement. I am all for clear guidelines/parameters being provided by the state to assist with these negotiations but afraid that the current tension as a result of these recent policy changes (i.e., APPR) will only hinder schools progress.
Collaboration is the key! Teachers cannot be painted as the enemy to the public in order for these controversial policies to be passed and politicians need to take responsibility that the only reason why unions have become so powerful is because of their prior support. I completely agree with William Even, an economics professor at Miami University of Ohio, who said “the law resulted from another difference between the parties. There’s a definite philosophical disagreement between the Republicans and Democrats about what unions do to the efficiency of government operations and whether unions have led to overcompensation for public workers.”
I agree that a tax cap has its problems especially for the neediest schools. Unfortunately, I believe this is only going to cause more inequalities between the “haves” and “have nots”. But something has to be done because of the skyrocketing costs and no other formula has been proposed. I agree that federal and state mandates need to be examined and monies need to be set aside if districts continue to be accountable. I hear too often about the costs of special education mandates (“The Legislature enjoys passing laws without giving locals the money to pay for them. Take special education, which at more than $24,000 per student is far more expensive in New York than in most other states. For years, lawmakers have added 257 additional requirements to federal disabilities laws, according to the Citizens Budget Commission”). However, as an administrator and advocate for special education it is difficult for me to want these mandates to be removed. Many of these mandates were designed to protect the rights of the students with disabilities and resulted from the injustices they faced by our education system in previous years. However, I do agree with removing the “access fat” and support requiring districts to obtain competitive bids for quality services. I am also a supporter for the government to examine the costs of litigations and the how the regulations/procedures are lopsided putting the district at a disadvantage for prevailing on cases (i.e., private tuition reimbursement). The idea for district consolidation is worth considering because it can save money, promote diversity, and enhance curriculum. This too will be a hard sale especially for high-performing suburban school districts. What we can do right now at the local level is to start conversations with neighboring districts to share resources and consolidate school activities in an attempt to save costs as well as promote meaningful collaboration across schools/communities. Only together can we solve these tough problems…..
Many interesting points here, Nicole. Regarding special education mandates,while we all agree that there should be some protection to assure that students needs are met, districts are legally bound to comply with so many laborious and costly regs that make no sense for kids....and then to pay the cost of doing so. Seems to me that there's much to be done to relieve unfunded mandates in this area, without any loss of meaningful services to kids. It might be interesting for someone to turn the tables and examine the 'value-added' of some of the burdensome regs imposed on schools!
ReplyDeleteWhat's the solution to this dilemma?
ReplyDeleteWell, I don't know, but this should be a fun exercise either way. Here are my opinions:
Regarding Unions -
1. I think it is important to understand the reason unions began. They were originally formed to protect members from abusive employers who wanted to take advantage of them. Having a "union" essentially provided protection and relief to the "employee" side of the relationship. At this point, many unions have overthrown this balance of power to the point that the employees now maintain even more power than the employer.
2. Although this is a separate issue from unions, it is also important to understand the origins of tenure. Originally, tenure was developed to ensure "academic freedom." In other words, it was intended to allow researchers to pursue areas of study without having to worry about publishing unfavorable results, etc. It also served to allow teachers to grade their pupils fairly, and without fear of unfair pressure from outside sources. Perhaps the highest form of "tenure" (although I don't think they call it tenure) is when a Justice is appointed to the Supreme Court. They are given the job for the rest of their life. The purpose of this ultimate “job security” as well as their high salary is to prevent them from being influenced by external factors (political pressure, bribes, etc.) when rendering decisions. There is a fascinating book by Jeffrey Toobin called "The Nine" on this topic if you are interested.
3. Now this may not make me very popular, but I do not see why tenure or unions are essential in public education. In his memoir, "From the Gut," Jack Welch (former CEO at GE) talks about how their organization systematically evaluates employees and cuts the bottom 15% in every department. When you compare the progress and innovation that has come from GE over the past 100 years next to public education for the same time period, it is staggering how pitifully slow we (educators) have moved. Can you believe that some school administrators are still spending precious time attempting to get reticent teachers to check their emails everyday? What would education look like today if it were not cost prohibitive (both financially and temporally) to expel incompetent educators? What benefit do unions have on students? Seriously, what do you all think? I can't tell you how many times I have paid a sub to cover a teachers’ class for 45 minutes because she missed her prep.
Regarding the Tax-Cap –
1. I agree that the tax cap is a “blunt instrument.” But, what’s the alternative? With unfunded mandates as well as powerful unions and lobbyists, I can’t imagine another way of forcing districts to control their spending. What I think will need to happen now, more than ever, is for school districts to educated tax payers and provide them with choices for the type of school district they want to have in their communities. When we shop for a car, it is obvious: You can buy a brand new 4-cylinder, cloth seated, hub-capped Toyota Corolla for $13,000 or a 12 cylinder, Lamborghini with your name monogrammed in the headrests for $250,000. Both will get you across town, but in very different ways. I think tax-payers will need to weigh in on what they want.
2. The editor of the times article states that NY does not distribute funds to schools in an equitable way. I am not sure if this is the case, or not, but I am not sure I would agree that the “least well off districts need the more money.” That seems too linear as there are many other variables to consider.
3. From an economic standpoint, I did like the author’s idea of consolidating school districts. There are some positions where scale is less important (i.e. assistant superintendent for curriculum) and other positions where student to employee ratios are more vital (i.e. classroom teacher).
Interesting comments, Jeff. Regarding unions, I think most agree that reform is needed, though it remains to be seen how we will get there while maintaining quality of programs and good will with staff: a delicate, though surmountable challenge, I think.
ReplyDeleteAs for the tax cap, even if we were to agree that it is a 'necessary evil', as you've suggested, I question the fairness of the need for a supermajority override. That seems a bit artitrary to me, especially since the current system is structured as
one of 'local control'. Seems as if that's getting a bit lost in the translation of all of this.
Jeff, I am so frustrated with incompetent teachers as well. I am tired of their complaining and lack of patience with the students. I do not agree with the tenure system and would love to see another system in place. My only worry is subjectivity. Yes, one way to save money could be the removal of those incompetent teachers…old, young and in between. However, with or without tenure in place, fair and objective measures must be used. Unfortunately, cuts may have to extend well beyond the firing of incompetent teachers.
ReplyDeleteI am also interested in the history of tenure and unions. Again, I agree with you! Unions started out protecting and have increasingly evolved into power.
Diane Ravitch states,
“It is worth recalling why teachers joined unions and why unions remain important today. Take tenure, for example. The teacher unions didn't invent tenure, despite widespread beliefs to the contrary. Tenure evolved in the 19th century as one of the few perks available to people who were paid low wages, had classes of 70 or 80 or more, and endured terrible working conditions.”
“The essentials of good education are the same everywhere: a rigorous curriculum, effective instruction, adequate resources, willing students, and a social and cultural climate in which education is encouraged and respected. Teacher unions today, as in the past, must work to make these essentials available in every district for every school and every student. They cannot do it alone. They must work with administrators and elected officials to advance these goals. The unions will continue to be important, vital, and needed so long as they speak on behalf of the rights and dignity of teachers and the essentials of good education.”(Why Teacher Unions Are Good for Teachers and the Public- They Protect Teachers’ Rights, Support Teacher Professionalism, and Check Administrative Power).
I believe good education relies on all of the above as stated by Ravitch. Times have changed drastically however. The Teacher Unions need more than ever to work together for every student and every school.
I agree that incompetence should be a priority of any evaluation system. However, we need to stop inferring that teachers and administrators are incompetent. It does exist but in my experience it is a small fraction of all educators. Again, incompetence should not be tolerated. What happens when the few are removed? We will still need to focus on our students and learning. So focus there now. I just returned from a conference where I met Dr. King. He spoke about the need for an effective performance management system. He cited the auto industry which made cuts to research and development and performance management. Dr. King spoke about the auto industry’s collapse caused by these cuts. I fear we are trying to enhance a management system during a time of economic cuts. Our district (as most others) is talking about cuts including administrative positions. There may not be enough time in our day to continue to meet to challenge of the current reform movement even if all positions survive, let alone if they are cut. Dr. King spoke about administrators using their time and resources differently. I agree, but if cuts come, who will do everything? The common core and data driven instruction have merit, but we need people to see them through.
ReplyDeleteRandi Weingarten – former head of the American Federation of Teachers- states that schools with unionized teachers show better student performance: “the states that actually have lots of teachers in teacher unions tend to be the states that have done the best in terms of academic success in this country. And the states that don't tend to be the worst.” Teacher unions effect on student performance needs consideration in this debate. Weingarten’s claims were found to be valid. A 2000 study by the Harvard Educational Review found a "[c]omparison of standardized test scores and degree of teacher unionization in states found a statistically significant and positive relationship between the presence of teacher unions and stronger state performance on tests.” A 2002 qualitative study by an Indiana University professor showed that “the evidence suggests that unionism raises achievement modestly for most students in public schools." While there remains to be limited research in the area of teacher unions and the effects on student performance, the research that has been conducted is positive; Nathan Burroughs from the Center for Evaluation and Education Policy states: “the overall pattern in the research is increasingly clear; teacher unionism favorably influences achievement for most students in public schools." (http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2010/sep/02/randi-weingarten/randi-weingarten-says-students-strong-union-states/).
ReplyDeleteLisa, some very interesting points regarding unions and its effectiveness. I agree, that there is limited research in the area of teacher unions and the effects on student performance; however, we must all remain positive. Ineffective teachers are a liability to our system. It's difficult to "get rid" of a tenured teacher, not impossible. It takes some time and due dillegence. Administrators should work with the union to address teacher ineffectiveness. I am sure we all want what's best for children.
ReplyDelete