Given such difficult economic times, governments and school districts are under increased pressure to curb school funding and, therefore, taxation. Currently, two fundamental approaches -- limiting collective bargaining rights (ex. Wisconsin, Ohio) and imposing tax caps (ex. CA, NY, NJ) -- are in the forefront of solutions being implemented in various states. Clearly, neither is universally popular (as evidenced by links below) and yet, the public is demanding change.
What's the solution to this dilemma? That's the focus of this next round of blogging.
Although there's endless material on this subject, the following two pieces from NewYorkTimes will get us started...
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/05/opinion/05tue2.html?emc=eta1
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/22/opinion/22wed1.html?emc=eta1
Your thoughts?
I do agree with Jim’s statement, “Professionally speaking, when adults sit down and rationally exchange ideas and discuss best practices a great deal can get accomplished.” My question: How does one describe, “best practice” now? I believe educators have one idea and those that serve on Boards of Education might have another.”
ReplyDeleteNot only are schools being threatened financially, but also philosophically. The focus of teaching the whole child and using instructional methods that benefit the progress of each student has turned into teaching to raise test scores. Teachers and administrators are getting too distracted. Everyone is worried. The climate of schools is changing. More and more lessons are scripted where every teacher is fully expected to be on the same page at the same time. Curriculum maps are becoming timelines. Race to the Top has become, “Race to Get the Lessons Done”, “Race to Interpret Data” and “Race to Increase Scores”.
Let’s not forget about, “Race for Merit Pay”! Ohio’s office of collective bargaining estimates that replacing statutory step pay increases with merit pay will save the state $75 million a year and local governments $393 million a year.
We need to refocus away from, “The Race” and more on what our children need.
I am not sure if anyone saw the documentary, Waiting for Superman, but with regard to merit pay, I found it interesting that when Michelle Rhee proposed doubling teachers' salaries in exchange for tenure, the union would not even bring it to the members for consideration.
ReplyDeleteJeff, I am so frustrated with incompetent teachers as well. I am tired of their complaining and lack of patience with the students. I do not agree with the tenure system and would love to see another system in place. My only worry is subjectivity. Yes, one way to save money could be the removal of those incompetent teachers…old, young and in between. However, with or without tenure in place, fair and objective measures must be used. Unfortunately, cuts may have to extend well beyond the firing of incompetent teachers.
ReplyDeleteI am also interested in the history of tenure and unions. Again, I agree with you! Unions started out protecting and have increasingly evolved into power.
Diane Ravitch states,
“It is worth recalling why teachers joined unions and why unions remain important today. Take tenure, for example. The teacher unions didn't invent tenure, despite widespread beliefs to the contrary. Tenure evolved in the 19th century as one of the few perks available to people who were paid low wages, had classes of 70 or 80 or more, and endured terrible working conditions.”
“The essentials of good education are the same everywhere: a rigorous curriculum, effective instruction, adequate resources, willing students, and a social and cultural climate in which education is encouraged and respected. Teacher unions today, as in the past, must work to make these essentials available in every district for every school and every student. They cannot do it alone. They must work with administrators and elected officials to advance these goals. The unions will continue to be important, vital, and needed so long as they speak on behalf of the rights and dignity of teachers and the essentials of good education.”(Why Teacher Unions Are Good for Teachers and the Public- They Protect Teachers’ Rights, Support Teacher Professionalism, and Check Administrative Power).
I believe good education relies on all of the above as stated by Ravitch. Times have changed drastically however. The Teacher Unions need more than ever to work together for every student and every school.
“We can't solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them.” – Albert Einstein.
ReplyDeleteWhat is the best solution(s) to the economic pressures facing our schools? How are schools to achieve and succeed while under public pressure to do more with less? Cuomo’s solution of a tax cap seems problematic in many ways. As stated in the New York Times Editorial, The Tax-Cap Illusion, [h]istory shows, painfully, that caps can do more harm than good.” The New York State School Boards Association’s projection of a collective nearly billion dollar shortfall to be felt by district statewide as a result of the tax cap is concerning. How will schools make up a multi-million dollar deficit without deteriorating? The decisions we make today will affect our schools long term. And this approach will ultimately lead to further inequity between rich and poor. “The effects of tax caps are more powerful in bad economic times, and in poorer neighborhoods. Many tax caps — like the one in New Jersey — can be overturned by a majority of voters in a district. Richer communities tend to agree to the higher taxes, usually to improve their schools. Poorer ones more often go without.” - The Tax-Cap Illusion. It is the rural districts and schools in poorer communities that will feel the major effects of the tax cap. This approach does not address the reasons for increases in educational spending, but forces reform in uncertain directions.
Jeff, I am so frustrated with incompetent teachers as well. I am tired of their complaining and lack of patience with the students. I do not agree with the tenure system and would love to see another system in place. My only worry is subjectivity. Yes, one way to save money could be the removal of those incompetent teachers…old, young and in between. However, with or without tenure in place, fair and objective measures must be used. Unfortunately, cuts may have to extend well beyond the firing of incompetent teachers.
ReplyDeleteHi Monique,
Regarding your comment above...
I understand your concerns about "fair and objective measures" for evaluating teachers, especially when future employment is on the line. However, just as the percentage of ineffective teachers accounts for an extremely small percentage, so too, is the percentage of unscrupulous administrators who would use their authority to make the employment decisions "personal." And if an administrator were to misuse their authority, then they need to be held accountable too!
I think many would agree with your comment because we it appears we would rather err on the side of caution. Unfortunately, the other side of this equation is the students who are stuck with poor teachers. They are the ones who pay the price.
I am not really sure if I am for or against tenure... it is just my opinion that the current laws make it too difficult to get rid of ineffective teachers, which is a shame-- not only for the students who are under served, but also for the reputation of the many outstanding teachers in the field.
The Journal News – 11/2/11 pg.10A
ReplyDeleteAs tax cap starts, groups press for mandate relief by Jon Campbell
In today’s Journal News, a coalition of advocacy groups put out a six-point plan they say would help relieve local governments from state mandates. However, labor unions say they are ready to aggressively fight the proposal. The pension plans for new public workers would be one of the revisions being considered. I plan to address these plans in my presentation on December 8, 2011. Pension costs seem to be a hot topic with many. It was sad to read that Danny Donohue, CSEA Union President, called then coalition’s plan “a perversion of reality” and “bile,” calling it a “front group” for Cuomo. This type of rhetoric accomplishes nothing.